Skip to content 
Buying an existing business is often faster and less risky than starting one from scratch. You get a proven concept, an existing customer base, and immediate cash flow. However, acquiring a company is not just a financial transaction; it is a complex legal transfer filled with potential landmines. If you don’t look closely at the fine print, you might inherit debts, lawsuits, or regulatory headaches that could sink your investment before you even start.
This guide walks you through the critical legal considerations of buying a small business. From the initial due diligence to the final signature on the purchase agreement, understanding these legalities will help you close the deal with confidence.
Why Legal Due Diligence Matters
Contents
Before you negotiate a price, you need to know exactly what you are buying. Legal due diligence is the investigative phase where you and your attorney peel back the layers of the business to verify its legal standing. This isn’t just about checking the bank accounts; it’s about ensuring the business owns what it claims to own and isn’t hiding any nasty surprises.
Think of it like buying a used car. You wouldn’t just kick the tires; you’d check the title, look for accident reports, and make sure the engine isn’t about to blow. In business, “checking the engine” means reviewing corporate documents, contracts, and compliance records.
Structuring the Deal: Asset vs. Stock Purchase
One of the first legal decisions you will make is how to structure the purchase. This usually falls into two categories: an asset purchase or a stock purchase.
Asset Purchase:
In an asset purchase, you buy specific assets of the company—equipment, inventory, customer lists, and goodwill. You generally do not assume the company’s liabilities unless you explicitly agree to them. This is often the preferred method for buyers because it minimizes risk. You get the good stuff without inheriting the bad history.
Stock Purchase:
In a stock purchase, you buy the owner’s shares of the corporation. This means you step into the seller’s shoes completely. You get everything: the assets, the brand, and importantly, all past, present, and future liabilities. If the company was sued five years ago or owes back taxes, that is now your problem. While riskier, this method can sometimes be simpler for transferring contracts and licenses that might not be assignable in an asset sale.
Uncovering Hidden Liabilities
When you take over a business, you want a clean slate. Unfortunately, liabilities have a way of clinging to businesses like barnacles. Your legal team needs to scrutinize several areas to ensure you aren’t walking into a trap.
Debts and Liens
Run a UCC (Uniform Commercial Code) search to see if any creditors have liens against the business assets. If the previous owner used the pizza ovens as collateral for a loan they haven’t paid off, the bank could repossess your equipment after you buy the business. You need clear title to every asset you purchase.
Pending Litigation
Is the business currently being sued? Has it been sued in the past? Are there threats of litigation? A disgruntled employee suing for wrongful termination or a customer claiming injury on the premises can cost you thousands in legal fees. Your purchase agreement should include warranties from the seller stating that there is no undisclosed litigation.
Tax Obligations
If the seller hasn’t paid their sales tax, payroll tax, or income tax, the government may come looking for you. This is known as “successor liability.” In many jurisdictions, tax authorities can hold the purchaser responsible for the seller’s unpaid taxes up to the purchase price of the business. Always require a tax clearance certificate from the state to prove the seller’s accounts are current.
Contract Review: What Are You Inheriting?
A business is largely defined by its relationships, which are governed by contracts. You need to read every single one.
Leases
For many small businesses, specifically retail or restaurants, the location is the most valuable asset. You must review the commercial lease carefully.
- Assignability: Can the lease be transferred to you? Many landlords require approval before a lease can be assigned to a new owner.
- Terms: How much time is left on the lease? If it expires in six months, do you have an option to renew?
- Cost: Are there scheduled rent increases that will impact your profitability?
Supplier and Vendor Agreements
Does the business rely on a specific supplier for a key component? Check if they have a long-term contract and if the terms are favorable. More importantly, check if the contract includes a “change of control” clause. This clause might allow the supplier to cancel the contract or renegotiate prices if the business changes owners.
Customer Contracts
If you are buying a B2B service business, your revenue depends on existing customer contracts. You need to ensure these contracts are valid, enforceable, and transferrable. If the top three clients account for 80% of revenue and their contracts are about to expire, the business might be worth far less than the asking price.
Protecting Intellectual Property (IP)
In the digital age, Intellectual Property is often more valuable than physical equipment. You need to verify that the seller actually owns the IP they are selling.
Trademarks and Branding
Does the business own the trademark for its name and logo? If they have been operating for years without registering the trademark, another company might technically own the rights, forcing you to rebrand later. Ensure all trademarks are properly registered with the USPTO (or relevant local authority) and are in good standing.
Copyrights and Software
If the business sells software, creative works, or proprietary content, you must ensure they own the copyright. Be careful with work created by independent contractors. Unless there was a written agreement assigning the copyright to the company (“work made for hire”), the contractor might still own the rights to the code or design they created.
Trade Secrets
Customer lists, recipes, and manufacturing processes are trade secrets. You need to ensure the seller has taken reasonable steps to protect them, such as having employees sign Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs). If everyone in town knows the “secret sauce,” it’s not an asset you should pay a premium for.
Employee and Labor Issues
Employees are the lifeblood of a small business, but they also represent significant legal compliance obligations.
Employment Agreements
Review all employment contracts. Are there key executives with golden parachutes? Are there non-compete agreements that prevent key salespeople from leaving and taking clients with them? You need to know if you are legally bound to keep certain staff or if you can restructure the team.
Benefits and Compliance
Check if the business is compliant with wage and hour laws, workers’ compensation insurance, and anti-discrimination laws. If the seller misclassified employees as independent contractors to save on taxes, you could be liable for back taxes and penalties.
The Purchase Agreement: sealing the Deal
The definitive purchase agreement is the master document that governs the entire transaction. It should be drafted or reviewed by an experienced business attorney.
Representations and Warranties
These are statements of fact made by the seller. For example, “The seller represents that the financial statements are accurate” or “The seller warrants that there is no pending litigation.” If these turn out to be false later, you have legal grounds to sue for breach of contract.
Indemnification
This is your safety net. An indemnification clause requires the seller to reimburse you for any losses resulting from their pre-closing actions. If a lawsuit pops up regarding an event that happened two years ago, the seller pays for it, not you.
Non-Compete Clauses
The last thing you want is to buy a business, only to have the previous owner open a competing shop across the street three months later. A non-compete clause restricts the seller from starting a similar business within a certain geographic area for a specific period (e.g., 50 miles for 5 years). Note that the enforceability of non-competes varies by state, so local legal advice is crucial here.
Regulatory Compliance and Permits
Every industry has its own red tape. You must ensure the business has all the necessary licenses to operate legally.
- Zoning: Is the business operating in a zone approved for its use?
- Health and Safety: Does the restaurant pass health inspections? Does the manufacturing plant meet OSHA standards?
- Environmental Regulations: This is critical for businesses like dry cleaners, gas stations, or auto repair shops. You could be liable for environmental cleanup costs if the soil or groundwater is contaminated, even if you didn’t cause the spill.
Conclusion
Buy a small business is an exciting path to entrepreneurship, but the legal landscape is dense. The excitement of a new venture can easily overshadow the boring, gritty details of contracts and compliance. However, ignoring these details is a recipe for disaster.
To protect your investment, assemble a team of professionals—including a business attorney and an accountant—early in the process. Conduct rigorous due diligence, scrutinize every contract, and ensure your purchase agreement offers robust protection. By handling the legal side with care, you clear the path for your future success.
Leave a Reply